| # | Tournament | Winning Team | Winner Score | Losing Team | Loser Score |
| 1* | Disabilities Awareness (Paper | 'Merica | 13 | BABS | 2 |
| 2* | Disabilities Awareness (Paper | 'Merica | 13 | FCancer | 5 |
| 3* | Disabilities Awareness (Paper | 'Merica | 21 | Bomb Squad | 10 |
| 4* | Disabilities Awareness (Paper | 'Merica | 27 | Ruff Riders | 15 |
| 5* | Disabilities Awareness (Paper | 'Merica | 24 | Mud Cats | 18 |
| 6* | Disabilities Awareness (Paper | HDLNS | 22 | 'Merica | 7 |
| 7* | 22nd Annual Bash for Cash GSL | 'Merica | 14 | Playground Swingers | 4 |
| 8 | 22nd Annual Bash for Cash GSL | RD Softball | 7 | 'Merica | 0 |
| 9 | 22nd Annual Bash for Cash GSL | 'Merica | 7 | JPS Lanterns | 0 |
| 10 | 22nd Annual Bash for Cash GSL | 'Merica | 25 | RD Softball | 23 |
| 11 | 22nd Annual Bash for Cash GSL | 'Merica | 32 | RD Softball | 20 |
| 12 | 22nd Annual Men's E, 35 & Co- | 'Merica | 15 | Audrey'sFrogtownTavern/Mo | 14 |
| 13* | 22nd Annual Men's E, 35 & Co- | Cinci venom | 12 | 'Merica | 8 |
| 14* | 22nd Annual Men's E, 35 & Co- | La familia | 14 | 'Merica | 4 |
| 15* | 22nd Annual Men's E, 35 & Co- | 'Merica | 17 | Cinci venom | 6 |
| 16* | 22nd Annual Men's E, 35 & Co- | 'Merica | 26 | Fire & Ice | 6 |
| 17* | 22nd Annual Men's E, 35 & Co- | 'Merica | 14 | Ruff Riders | 11 |
| 18 | 22nd Annual Men's E, 35 & Co- | 'Merica | 8 | Audrey'sFrogtownTavern/Mo | 7 |
| 19 | 22nd Annual Men's E, 35 & Co- | Audrey'sFrogtownTavern/Mo | 11 | 'Merica | 9 |
| 20 | 2023 Cincinnati Metro Softball | RD Softball | 12 | 'Merica | 9 |
| 21* | 2023 Cincinnati Metro Softball | GSOD | 16 | 'Merica | 6 |
| 22* | Pitching for Paws Catching for | 'Merica | 29 | The Sauce | 8 |
| 23* | Pitching for Paws Catching for | 'Merica | 20 | goon squad | 7 |
| 24 | Pitching for Paws Catching for | 'Merica | 7 | RD Softball | 6 |
| 25* | Pitching for Paws Catching for | Multiple Scoregasms | 14 | 'Merica | 3 |
* Indicates games played against teams of different class. Updated every night. The first day results are entered all games will appear in tan. |