| # | Tournament | Winning Team | Winner Score | Losing Team | Loser Score |
| 1* | GSL MIKEN HEROES FUND | 'Merica/ Rice Law | 20 | Mud Cats | 8 |
| 2* | GSL MIKEN HEROES FUND | Mahalo | 11 | Mud Cats | 1 |
| 3 | GSL MIKEN HEROES FUND | Banditos | 38 | Mud Cats | 20 |
| 4 | SOFTBALL SURVIVOR 2022 | WAP/Tip-Top Roofing | 22 | Mud Cats | 1 |
| 5* | SOFTBALL SURVIVOR 2022 | DSD/FAFO | 12 | Mud Cats | 2 |
| 6* | SOFTBALL SURVIVOR 2022 | Mud Cats | 16 | La Familia | 15 |
| 7* | SOFTBALL SURVIVOR 2022 | Mud Cats | 21 | Cincy Shockers | 11 |
| 8* | Prize-A-Palooza | Mahalo | 23 | Mud Cats | 14 |
| 9 | Prize-A-Palooza | Mud Cats | 10 | Banditos | 9 |
| 10* | Prize-A-Palooza | 'Merica/ Rice Law | 14 | Mud Cats | 9 |
| 11* | 70th Annual Cincy Metro | RD Softball | 20 | Mud Cats | 6 |
| 12 | 70th Annual Cincy Metro | Mud Cats | 8 | Banditos | 5 |
| 13* | 70th Annual Cincy Metro | Mud Cats | 18 | OG Cleaning Services Inc. | 8 |
| 14* | 70th Annual Cincy Metro | Mahalo | 21 | Mud Cats | 13 |
| 18 | GSL Midwest Championship Coed | Belly's/ BDE | 28 | Mud Cats | 4 |
| 19 | GSL Midwest Championship Coed | Built Diffrent | 20 | Mud Cats | 5 |
| 20 | GSL Midwest Championship Coed | Banditos | 10 | Mud Cats | 6 |
| 21* | Fright Night (Paper Roster) | Mud Cats | 17 | The Sauce | 14 |
| 22* | Fright Night (Paper Roster) | Mud Cats | 18 | Mysfunctionals | 3 |
| 23* | Fright Night (Paper Roster) | Mud Cats | 18 | Khaos-Kachow | 3 |
| 24* | Fright Night (Paper Roster) | Mud Cats | 18 | Last Picked | 1 |
| 25 | Fright Night (Paper Roster) | Mud Cats | 13 | Banditos | 6 |
| 26* | Turkey Bash (Paper Roster) | Mud Cats | 31 | La Familia | 19 |
| 27* | Turkey Bash (Paper Roster) | Mud Cats | 24 | Warm Apple Pie | 19 |
| 28* | Turkey Bash (Paper Roster) | Mud Cats | 19 | RD Softball | 9 |
| 29* | Turkey Bash (Paper Roster) | BOH | 17 | Mud Cats | 9 |
| 30* | Turkey Bash (Paper Roster) | Scissor Gang | 20 | Mud Cats | 18 |
* Indicates games played against teams of different class. Updated every night. The first day results are entered all games will appear in tan. |