| Player Tournament Awards | Players Name | Plays For | Stature | Tournament | Season |
| Defensive Tournament MVP | Dan Tolbert | TigerFitness/YoderBuildings/SOCC/BC | League - Slowpitch | 23rd Annual City Slam | 2024 |
|
| Defensive Tournament MVP | Sam Lawson | Flys Guys/MAB/Birdman Creations | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | 9th Annual Slugfest | 2023 |
|
| Defensive Tournament MVP | Doug Teegarden | Fly's Guys/MAB | Qualifier - GSL - Points | 3rd Annual John Kings Softball Tournament | 2022 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Sean Melampy | Freeze Concrete/Jas. S. Arnold/BW3/ | NIT - USSSA - Berth | Men's B/C NIT | 2006 |
|
| Tournament CO-MVP | Sean Melampy | MWC/Pipe/Mojo/DSS Bats/Easton | State - USSSA | Ohio Open B/C State Championship | 2010 |
|
| Defensive Tournament MVP | Dan Tolbert | Bellagio/Yoder Buildings | State - GSL | GSL OHIO STATE | 2026 |
|
| All Tournament Team | James Hansee | Cincysoftball.com / Hdlns | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | 15th Annual Bash for Cash | 2016 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Andrew Chase | Fly's Guys | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | 18th Annual USSSA Bash for Cash | 2019 |
| All Tournament Team | Andrew Chase | Fly's Guys | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | 18th Annual USSSA Bash for Cash | 2019 |
| All Tournament Team | Andrew Chase | Fly's Guys | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | 18th Annual USSSA Bash for Cash | 2019 |
| All Tournament Team | Andrew Chase | Fly's Guys | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | 18th Annual USSSA Bash for Cash | 2019 |
| All Tournament Team | Joey Va | Fly's Guys | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | 18th Annual USSSA Bash for Cash | 2019 |
| All Tournament Team | Joey Va | Fly's Guys | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | 18th Annual USSSA Bash for Cash | 2019 |
|
| Tournament MVP | Sean Melampy | Headlines/The Association/TCHOA | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | 18th Annual City Slam I | 2019 |
| Tournament MVP | Sean Melampy | Headlines/The Association/TCHOA | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | 18th Annual City Slam I | 2019 |
| All Tournament Team | Adam Sorrell | Headlines/The Association/TCHOA | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | 18th Annual City Slam I | 2019 |
| All Tournament Team | Adam Sorrell | Headlines/The Association/TCHOA | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | 18th Annual City Slam I | 2019 |
| All Tournament Team | Matt Tucker | Headlines/The Association/TCHOA | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | 18th Annual City Slam I | 2019 |
| All Tournament Team | Matt Tucker | Headlines/The Association/TCHOA | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | 18th Annual City Slam I | 2019 |
|
| Tournament MVP | Sean Melampy | TigerFitness/Yoder Buildings/SOCC | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | 22nd Annual City Slam | 2023 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Andrew Hitchcock | Steve’s Elite/GRZY | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | 23rd Annual USSSA Bash for Cash | 2024 |
| All Tournament Team | Dan Tolbert | TigerFitness/YoderBuildings/SOCC/BC | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | 23rd Annual USSSA Bash for Cash | 2024 |
|
| Tournament MVP | Dan Tolbert | TigerFitness/YoderBuildings/SOCC/BC | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | John Kings Cincy Bash | 2024 |
| Defensive Tournament MVP | Sean Melampy | Legacy/GRZY | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | John Kings Cincy Bash | 2024 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Christopher Conner | Headlines Sportswear / CSB | Qualifier - GSL - Points | Miken's Heroes Fund | 2017 |
| All Tournament Team | Sam Lawson | TEAM JAWN | Qualifier - GSL - Points | Miken's Heroes Fund | 2017 |
| All Tournament Team | Tyler Sexton | TEAM JAWN | Qualifier - GSL - Points | Miken's Heroes Fund | 2017 |
|
| Tournament CO-MVP | Tyler Sexton | Fly's Guys/HDLNS/Buffalo Joe's | Qualifier - GSL - Points | Miken Heroes Mission | 2020 |
| All Tournament Team | Jeremy Conley | Fly's Guys/HDLNS/Buffalo Joe's | Qualifier - GSL - Points | Miken Heroes Mission | 2020 |
| All Tournament Team | Sam Lawson | Fly's Guys/HDLNS/Buffalo Joe's | Qualifier - GSL - Points | Miken Heroes Mission | 2020 |
| All Tournament Team | Tanner Norton | Fly's Guys/HDLNS/Buffalo Joe's | Qualifier - GSL - Points | Miken Heroes Mission | 2020 |
| All Tournament Team | Doug Teegarden | Fly's Guys/HDLNS/Buffalo Joe's | Qualifier - GSL - Points | Miken Heroes Mission | 2020 |
| All Tournament Team | Doug Teegarden | Fly's Guys/HDLNS/Buffalo Joe's | Qualifier - GSL - Points | Miken Heroes Mission | 2020 |
|
| Tournament CO-MVP | Matt Tucker | EAP/Tigerfitness/K&W/Tyja/Worth | NIT - USSSA - Berth | Mens One Pitch NIT | 2011 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Adam Sorrell | Headlines Sportswear / CSB | GSL Super Dual NIT | MONEYBALL | 2017 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Sean Melampy | Headlines/The Association/TCHOA | GSL Super Dual NIT | 18th Annual Bash for Cash Super Dual NIT | 2019 |
| All Tournament Team | Sean Melampy | Headlines/The Association/TCHOA | GSL Super Dual NIT | 18th Annual Bash for Cash Super Dual NIT | 2019 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Andrew Hitchcock | DWS | GSL Super Dual NIT | 20th Annual GSL Bash for Cash Super Dual | 2021 |
| All Tournament Team | Sean Melampy | DWS | GSL Super Dual NIT | 20th Annual GSL Bash for Cash Super Dual | 2021 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Christopher Conner | Steve’s/GRZY | GSL Super Dual NIT | 22nd Annual Bash for Cash GSL Super Dual | 2023 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Adam Sorrell | Sportsco/Borgman/Turner | State - USSSA | USSSA Class C State Championship | 2011 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Matt Tucker | EAP/TigerFitness/HDLNS | State - USSSA | USSSA Mens C State | 2015 |
|
| Offensive Tournament MVP | Sean Melampy | Fly's Guys/HDLNS/Buffalo Joe's | State - USSSA | Men's GSL C, D & E Ohio South State Tournament | 2020 |
| All Tournament Team | Tyler Sexton | Fly's Guys/HDLNS/Buffalo Joe's | State - USSSA | Men's GSL C, D & E Ohio South State Tournament | 2020 |
| All Tournament Team | Adam Sorrell | Fly's Guys/HDLNS/Buffalo Joe's | State - USSSA | Men's GSL C, D & E Ohio South State Tournament | 2020 |
| All Tournament Team | Doug Teegarden | Fly's Guys/HDLNS/Buffalo Joe's | State - USSSA | Men's GSL C, D & E Ohio South State Tournament | 2020 |
| All Tournament Team | Dan Tolbert | Fly's Guys/HDLNS/Buffalo Joe's | State - USSSA | Men's GSL C, D & E Ohio South State Tournament | 2020 |
| All Tournament Team | Matt Tucker | Fly's Guys/HDLNS/Buffalo Joe's | State - USSSA | Men's GSL C, D & E Ohio South State Tournament | 2020 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Adam Sorrell | Tiger Fitness/Fly's Guys | State - GSL | Men's GSL C, D, E, Women's & Co-Ed Spring State | 2021 |
| All Tournament Team | Doug Teegarden | Tiger Fitness/Fly's Guys | State - GSL | Men's GSL C, D, E, Women's & Co-Ed Spring State | 2021 |
| All Tournament Team | Matt Tucker | Tiger Fitness/Fly's Guys | State - GSL | Men's GSL C, D, E, Women's & Co-Ed Spring State | 2021 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Christopher Conner | Sportsco/RTF/GRZY/Pure | State - GSL | GSL STATE TOURNAMENT | 2024 |
|
| Tournament MVP | Dan Tolbert | TigerFitness/YoderBuildings/SOCC/BC | State - Dual | ONE TRUE OHIO STATE TOURNAMENT | 2024 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Jeremy Conley | Fly's Guys/RDH/Gapper Apparel | State - Dual | USSSA ONE TRUE OHIO STATE | 2026 |
| All Tournament Team | Doug Teegarden | Fly's Guys/RDH/Gapper Apparel | State - Dual | USSSA ONE TRUE OHIO STATE | 2026 |
|
| Defensive Tournament MVP | Adam Sorrell | S&S Pools/TPE/Sportsco/Easton | Regional - USSSA | Great Lakes So. C National | 2013 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Sam Lawson | Tiger Fitness/Fly's Guys | World - GSL | GSL World Tournament - Midwest | 2021 |
| All Tournament Team | Adam Sorrell | Tiger Fitness/Fly's Guys | World - GSL | GSL World Tournament - Midwest | 2021 |
| All Tournament Team | Dan Tolbert | Tiger Fitness/Fly's Guys | World - GSL | GSL World Tournament - Midwest | 2021 |
|
| All Tournament Manager | Zach Shelton | No Excuses/Nat Flag Co/NCHGuns.com | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | COMP COLD BE GONE | 2014 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Brandon Markus | All Hustle | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | USSSA Strawberry Festival Dual NIT | 2017 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Joe Frey | Cincysoftball/Buffalo Joes/Willies | State - USSSA | Men D State Championship | 2012 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Sam Lawson | Team Jawn/ Monstars | State - USSSA | Men's "D" KY State Championships | 2014 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Sean Melampy | TF&G/Team Bailey/Reliable Tax/Selec | State - USSSA | Ohio D State Tournament | 2015 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Sam Lawson | Team Jawn | State - GSL | GSL Mens D State South | 2015 |
| All Tournament Team | Tyler Sexton | Team Jawn | State - GSL | GSL Mens D State South | 2015 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Sean Melampy | TF&G/Team Bailey/Reliable Tax/Selec | Regional - USSSA | USSSA D NATIONALS | 2015 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Andrew Hitchcock | Rays Boom Boom Room/Twistedsports | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | Great Lakes Mixed Fall Classic | 2016 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Andrew Hitchcock | Rays Boom Boom Room/Twistedsports | World - USSSA | USSSA Mixed World Tournament | 2016 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Adam Sorrell | Ohio | US Challenge Cup | USSSA Challenge Cup | 2022 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Jeremy Conley | Ohio - White | US Challenge Cup | USSSA Challenge Cup - Men's and Womens D & E | 2024 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Sam Lawson | Flys Guys/MAB/Birdman Creations | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | 22nd Annual City Slam | 2023 |
|
| Defensive Tournament MVP | Dan Tolbert | TigerFitness/YoderBuildings/SOCC/BC | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | 72nd Annual Cincinnati METRO Softball Tournament | 2024 |
| All Tournament Team | Sean Melampy | Legacy/GRZY | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | 72nd Annual Cincinnati METRO Softball Tournament | 2024 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Matt Tucker | EAP/Tigerfitness/K&W/Tyja/Worth | NIT - USSSA - Berth | Bud Light-Worth Men's Open NIT | 2011 |
|
| Defensive Tournament CO-MVP | Anthony Robinson | Cincysoftball/BuffloJoe/CroninFord | NIT - USSSA - Berth | TSC D/E Open NIT | 2013 |
|
| Tournament CO-MVP | Sean Melampy | Dill's Plumbing/PB Roofing/Citizevs | NIT - USSSA - Berth | 2013 B/C/D Jump Off TSC Event | 2013 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Joe Frey | Cincysoftball/BuffloJoe/CroninFord | NIT - USSSA - Berth | TSC Open NIT | 2013 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Sean Melampy | Action Sports/VHC/Miken | NIT - USSSA - Berth | 2014 Action Sports B/C Jump Off | 2014 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Christopher Conner | DTP/Headlines/#NoFilter | NIT - USSSA - Berth | 87th Schutzenfest D-E Open NIT | 2014 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Sam Lawson | Team Jawn/ Monstars | NIT - USSSA - Berth | TSC D-E Open NIT | 2014 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Joe Frey | Cincysoftball.com/Buffalo Joes/HDLN | NIT - USSSA - Berth | USSSA D/E TSC Open NIT WSQ | 2015 |