| Player Tournament Awards | Players Name | Plays For | Stature | Tournament | Season |
| All Tournament Team | Austin Elmore | TigerFitness/YoderBuildings/SOCC/BC | League - Slowpitch | 23rd Annual City Slam | 2024 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Brock Frentzel | MPT Rentals/Juno Athletics | Conference NIT - Men | Crown Town Classic | 2021 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Brock Frentzel | MPT Rentals/Juno Athletics | Conference NIT - Men | Schiffhauer Strong by Smash It Sports | 2021 |
|
| Tournament MVP | Brock Frentzel | Proton/Dan Smith/Legacy Glove Co. | Conference NIT Men Level 3 | Golden State Major | 2022 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Brock Frentzel | Proton/Dan Smith/Legacy Glove Co. | Conference NIT Men Level 3 | Salt Lake City Classic Major | 2022 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Brock Frentzel | ATARAXIS/SONNYS/JBLNEWBREEDKOVALBAF | Conference NIT Men Level 1 | Sin City Major | 2025 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Brock Frentzel | ATARAXIS/SONNYS/JBLNEWBREEDKOVALBAF | Conference NIT Men Level 1 | Salt Lake City Classic | 2025 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Brock Frentzel | ATARAXIS/SONNYS/JBLNEWBREEDKOVALBAF | Conference NIT Men Level 1 | Rocky Mountain Classic | 2025 |
|
| Tournament MVP | Brock Frentzel | ATARAXIS/SONNYS/JBLNEWBREEDKOVALBAF | Conference NIT Men Level 1 | Pocket City Dual Major | 2025 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Brock Frentzel | WestPoint | Conference NIT Men Level 1 | The Memorial Major | 2026 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Brock Frentzel | WestPoint | Conference NIT Men Level 1 | Battle On The Chesapeake Major | 2026 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Brock Frentzel | ANARCHY/MPT RENTALS | World - USSSA | Major World Series powered by Dudley | 2020 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Brock Frentzel | Proton/Dan Smith/Legacy Glove Co. | World - USSSA | Major World Series powered by Dudley | 2022 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Brock Frentzel | JBL Roofing/Pauer | World - USSSA | Men's Major World Series by Dudley | 2024 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Brock Frentzel | JBL Roofing/Pauer | World - USSSA | Men's AA World Tournament | 2024 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Brock Frentzel | ATARAXIS/SONNYS/JBLNEWBREEDKOVALBAF | World - USSSA | USSSA Men's AA World Tournament | 2025 |
|
| Tournament MVP | Scott Troyer | Old Bag/Unithreadz Apparel | State - Dual | USSSA Nationals C-D | 2020 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Logan Elmore | TigerFitness/YoderBuildings/SOCC/BC | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | 23rd Annual USSSA Bash for Cash | 2024 |
| All Tournament Team | Logan Elmore | TigerFitness/YoderBuildings/SOCC/BC | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | 23rd Annual USSSA Bash for Cash | 2024 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Michael Leytze | Flys Guys/MAB/Birdman Creations | GSL Super Dual NIT | 22nd Annual Bash for Cash GSL Super Dual | 2023 |
| All Tournament Team | Michael Leytze | TigerFitness/Yoder Buildings/SOCC | GSL Super Dual NIT | 22nd Annual Bash for Cash GSL Super Dual | 2023 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Matt Collins | FYC/Mojo USA | State - GSL | Men's GSL C, D, E, Women's & Co-Ed Spring State | 2021 |
| All Tournament Team | Michael Leytze | Tiger Fitness/Fly's Guys | State - GSL | Men's GSL C, D, E, Women's & Co-Ed Spring State | 2021 |
|
| Tournament CO-MVP | Kenny Jones | Cincinnati Dynasty | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | Great Lakes National | 2016 |
|
| Defensive Tournament MVP | Logan Elmore | Lookout/PauerSport/TF&G/Miken/Worth | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | USSSA D South State | 2018 |
| All Tournament Team | Logan Elmore | Lookout/PauerSport/TF&G/Miken/Worth | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | USSSA D South State | 2018 |
|
| Tournament MVP | Kenny Jones | Cincy's Finest | GSL Super Dual NIT | 18th Annual Bash for Cash Super Dual NIT | 2019 |
| Tournament MVP | Kenny Jones | Cincy's Finest | GSL Super Dual NIT | 18th Annual Bash for Cash Super Dual NIT | 2019 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Jeremy Webb | Xtreme Associates/BCP/ACS | State - USSSA | USSSA D Spring State Championship | 2012 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Kenny Jones | Wild Things | State - USSSA | USSSA STATE | 2021 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Travis Dray | FYC/Cotner Time | State - GSL | GSL Mens D State Tournament - North | 2019 |
| All Tournament Team | Travis Dray | FYC/Cotner Time | State - GSL | GSL Mens D State Tournament - North | 2019 |
|
| Defensive Tournament MVP | Jeremy Webb | FYC/Cotner Time | State - GSL | GSL South D & E State Tournament | 2019 |
| Defensive Tournament MVP | Jeremy Webb | FYC/Cotner Time | State - GSL | GSL South D & E State Tournament | 2019 |
| All Tournament Team | Travis Dray | FYC/Cotner Time | State - GSL | GSL South D & E State Tournament | 2019 |
| All Tournament Team | Travis Dray | FYC/Cotner Time | State - GSL | GSL South D & E State Tournament | 2019 |
|
| Tournament MVP | Jeremy Webb | RG | State Level 2 - USSSA | USSSA STATE TAVERNS | 2017 |
| All Tournament Team | Travis Dray | RG | State Level 2 - USSSA | USSSA STATE TAVERNS | 2017 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Gunnar Smeyres | Nature Boys | World - GSL | GSL World Tournament - Midwest | 2021 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Jeremy Webb | Mobile Care EMS & Transport/El Cami | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | Pacesetter Park E World Qualifier | 2010 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Gerald Burt | Stampede/ScottysPub/NCHGuns/SeeLife | NIT - USSSA - Berth | City Slam E NIT | 2013 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Nicholas Williams | Dayton League/ Oscars Bar & Grill | State Level 2 - USSSA | STATE TAVERNS BUDLIGHT DIVISION | 2013 |
|
| Defensive Tournament MVP | Jeremy Webb | Xtreme Assoc/BCP/Players WH | Regional - USSSA | Great Lakes National | 2011 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Brock Frentzel | Holes N Poles/Dbbrand/SNC/RB | World - USSSA | Mixed World Tournament | 2020 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Brock Frentzel | Holes & Poles/MPT/DBbrand | World - USSSA | USSSA Mixed World Tournament | 2021 |
|
| Tournament CO-MVP | Gerald Burt | So Icy | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | 9th Annual Dayton Legends coed equalizer | 2014 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Gerald Burt | Rays Boom Boom Room | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | Great Lakes Div Mixed Nationals | 2015 |
| All Tournament Team | Gerald Burt | So Icy | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | Great Lakes Div Mixed Nationals | 2015 |
|
| Tournament CO-MVP | Gerald Burt | So Icy | State - USSSA | Mixed D State | 2014 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Brock Frentzel | Ohio | US Challenge Cup | USSSA Challenge Cup M-Major, B, C, W-Major, C, & D | 2023 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Brock Frentzel | Ohio | US Challenge Cup | USSSA Challenge Cup - Major, B, C | 2025 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Kenny Jones | Cincinnati Dynasty | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | TSC Men Lower Open NIT | 2016 |
|
| Tournament MVP | Kenny Jones | Pitch Me One | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | 72nd Annual Cincinnati METRO Softball Tournament | 2024 |
| All Tournament Team | Austin Elmore | TigerFitness/YoderBuildings/SOCC/BC | Qualifier - USSSA - Points | 72nd Annual Cincinnati METRO Softball Tournament | 2024 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Travis Dray | Cotner Funeral Home | NIT - USSSA - Berth | TSC D/E Open NIT | 2013 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Gerald Burt | Stampede/ScottysPub/NCHGuns/SeeLife | NIT - USSSA - Berth | Armco Park Open NIT | 2013 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Jeremy Webb | Cotner Funeral Home | NIT - USSSA - Berth | 2014 4th Annual In It 2 Win It D/E | 2014 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Jeremy Webb | Cotner Funeral Home | NIT - USSSA - Berth | Men's Open D/E NIT | 2014 |
|
| All Tournament Team | Kenny Jones | Cincinnati Dynasty | NIT - USSSA - Berth | 87th Schutzenfest D-E Open NIT | 2014 |